I think ‘seriality’ was what I liked about delving into Moretti’s Graphs, Maps, Trees , Atlas of the European Novel, and the conversations that sprung up around them. The former book itself could almost be a tidied-up version of a blog:
Data is presented; questions are posed; alternative answers are explored, then rejected or partially accepted, as though we’re following Moretti’s discoveries as he makes them. At the end, we’re given a real geographer’s response to the book we’ve just read. Cozma Shalizi, the statistical physicist, reviews Atlas on his personal blog; then Moretti, Shalizi, and others get together for an open access book project about the discussions the original texts provoked. There’s a real conversational archive there, regardless of whether parts of it are on paid-for printed material or on free websites. If the conversation continues, one would be able to trace its contours and see how it ebbed and flowed in different directions, though always centered around some basic methodological questions.
I wonder if certain disciplines, topics, and modes of inquiry lend themselves to one or the other, seriality or surreality. If there’s tangible data, or specific questions, or a specific project, or a new method, I imagine seriality would evolve naturally. Hence, PLoS ONE for the scientists, university-sponsored working papers in linguistics, and the dozens of blogs about personal genomics. Maybe the humanities tend toward surreality simply because they don’t often operate with specific questions or set methods? I think your ‘overlapping synecdoches’ may arise because each humanities PhD is asking slightly (or completely) different questions and, along the same lines, rarely pairing up with other PhDs to tackle a specific problem or question that has dogged the entire community. Contra other disciplines, where PhDs get a PhD precisely by working on a big project in someone’s lab or in the field. There’s “work to do”, as it were, whereas humanities PhDs seem to “make work for themselves.”
^^An oversimplification, of course. And, as generative grammar demonstrates, sometimes too much persistence after a single question can be a vice. But I wonder if it’s a perceived lack of big questions, projects, and problems that pushes the humanities away from seriality? Which is unfortunate, because there are big questions, and even bigger ones that we haven’t formulated yet; there are projects to be done, problems to be solved . . . not the least of which is continuing, apropos your book, to develop a rhetoric of new media that doesn’t rely so heavily on alphabetic metaphors and heuristics.
Well, maybe I’ve misread your essay. In my linguistics classes, I can see how my most granular problem is still tied to someone else’s granular problem because each problem is tied to larger questions and a larger, discipline wide (or sub-discipline wide) project. So, maybe I’m reading into things here based on my current circumstances. However, I do know that in your DH class, I felt more like I do in my linguistics classes; I could look back at the end and see an edifice, a project, a field, an unfolding discussion. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve loved my other classes, but you could never put projects in those classes into anything like a unified wiki or serialized discussion.
I’ve thought a little about that too, Seth, the question of disciplinarity in this context. It might be interesting to go back to Susan Peck MacDonald’s book (which I’ll probably need to reread anyway for my next big project) and think through these issues there.
It’s also a big part of the reason why genre studies has been interesting to me lately–the fact that it’s actually several different disciplines all working towards articulating a larger set of questions and issues is endlessly fascinating to me, and the EAP/ESP part of it has to account for disciplinary differences.
I’ll certainly keep chewing on this, because there’s something that keeps us from striking a better balance than we have, and I don’t know that it’s all an issue of scholarly communication per se.
@cgbrooke
July 13, 2012 12:48 pm“Surreality,” my riff on @kfitz’s seriality posts http://t.co/Td2hoqj3
SethL
July 13, 2012 8:23 pmI think ‘seriality’ was what I liked about delving into Moretti’s Graphs, Maps, Trees , Atlas of the European Novel, and the conversations that sprung up around them. The former book itself could almost be a tidied-up version of a blog:
WhatILearnedFromCraploadsofBibliographies.wordpress.com
Data is presented; questions are posed; alternative answers are explored, then rejected or partially accepted, as though we’re following Moretti’s discoveries as he makes them. At the end, we’re given a real geographer’s response to the book we’ve just read. Cozma Shalizi, the statistical physicist, reviews Atlas on his personal blog; then Moretti, Shalizi, and others get together for an open access book project about the discussions the original texts provoked. There’s a real conversational archive there, regardless of whether parts of it are on paid-for printed material or on free websites. If the conversation continues, one would be able to trace its contours and see how it ebbed and flowed in different directions, though always centered around some basic methodological questions.
I wonder if certain disciplines, topics, and modes of inquiry lend themselves to one or the other, seriality or surreality. If there’s tangible data, or specific questions, or a specific project, or a new method, I imagine seriality would evolve naturally. Hence, PLoS ONE for the scientists, university-sponsored working papers in linguistics, and the dozens of blogs about personal genomics. Maybe the humanities tend toward surreality simply because they don’t often operate with specific questions or set methods? I think your ‘overlapping synecdoches’ may arise because each humanities PhD is asking slightly (or completely) different questions and, along the same lines, rarely pairing up with other PhDs to tackle a specific problem or question that has dogged the entire community. Contra other disciplines, where PhDs get a PhD precisely by working on a big project in someone’s lab or in the field. There’s “work to do”, as it were, whereas humanities PhDs seem to “make work for themselves.”
^^An oversimplification, of course. And, as generative grammar demonstrates, sometimes too much persistence after a single question can be a vice. But I wonder if it’s a perceived lack of big questions, projects, and problems that pushes the humanities away from seriality? Which is unfortunate, because there are big questions, and even bigger ones that we haven’t formulated yet; there are projects to be done, problems to be solved . . . not the least of which is continuing, apropos your book, to develop a rhetoric of new media that doesn’t rely so heavily on alphabetic metaphors and heuristics.
Well, maybe I’ve misread your essay. In my linguistics classes, I can see how my most granular problem is still tied to someone else’s granular problem because each problem is tied to larger questions and a larger, discipline wide (or sub-discipline wide) project. So, maybe I’m reading into things here based on my current circumstances. However, I do know that in your DH class, I felt more like I do in my linguistics classes; I could look back at the end and see an edifice, a project, a field, an unfolding discussion. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve loved my other classes, but you could never put projects in those classes into anything like a unified wiki or serialized discussion.
Collin
July 13, 2012 8:34 pmI’ve thought a little about that too, Seth, the question of disciplinarity in this context. It might be interesting to go back to Susan Peck MacDonald’s book (which I’ll probably need to reread anyway for my next big project) and think through these issues there.
It’s also a big part of the reason why genre studies has been interesting to me lately–the fact that it’s actually several different disciplines all working towards articulating a larger set of questions and issues is endlessly fascinating to me, and the EAP/ESP part of it has to account for disciplinary differences.
I’ll certainly keep chewing on this, because there’s something that keeps us from striking a better balance than we have, and I don’t know that it’s all an issue of scholarly communication per se.
Thanks for the comments…
cgb