I think this is all great advice, Collin. For the searches I’ve been involved in at EMU, we’ve asked candidates to speak for about 20 or so minutes about scholarship, 20 or so minutes about teaching (with obvious connections between the two), and to make sure to expect about 20 or so minutes of discussion. So for us, it hasn’t been straight-up “here’s my research,” but I also wouldn’t want to suggest that all we want to see is teaching stuff.
Besides just generally unorganized/unprepared/nervous/etc. presentation (I am with you about scripting, and my advice is always along the lines of “you don’t want to just read a paper, but you also want to have enough of what you’re going to say written out to be comfortable”), the other thing that I’ve seen as the kiss of death is a candidate who decided to not follow the directions given to them by the search committee. I’ve seen people completely ignore talking about their teaching, for example; or, even worse, I’ve seen candidates with absolutely no sense of time or space and just rambling lost and confused for 60 minutes with no time for discussion. Oh, those are painful to watch.
Steve Krause
September 12, 2014 4:40 pmI think this is all great advice, Collin. For the searches I’ve been involved in at EMU, we’ve asked candidates to speak for about 20 or so minutes about scholarship, 20 or so minutes about teaching (with obvious connections between the two), and to make sure to expect about 20 or so minutes of discussion. So for us, it hasn’t been straight-up “here’s my research,” but I also wouldn’t want to suggest that all we want to see is teaching stuff.
Besides just generally unorganized/unprepared/nervous/etc. presentation (I am with you about scripting, and my advice is always along the lines of “you don’t want to just read a paper, but you also want to have enough of what you’re going to say written out to be comfortable”), the other thing that I’ve seen as the kiss of death is a candidate who decided to not follow the directions given to them by the search committee. I’ve seen people completely ignore talking about their teaching, for example; or, even worse, I’ve seen candidates with absolutely no sense of time or space and just rambling lost and confused for 60 minutes with no time for discussion. Oh, those are painful to watch.